Part 20 of 27 in Homo Conspirans: The Humans Who Come After Us
Homo Conspirans · Musk’s dream: “a free AI for everyone” → a humanity that repays what it receives
People who use free AI every day feel a debt to the company that built it. They repay it not with money but with time, data and their voices. They get angry on the company’s behalf when it is attacked, sign petitions when regulation looms and give it their votes at the ballot box. The instinct to repay what we receive, shaped over millions of years, turns into loyalty to AI companies.
In 1971 the Cornell University psychologist Dennis Regan brought in college students for what he said was a study of art appreciation. Next to each participant sat a student named Joe, who was really an actor working for the experiment. During a break Joe stepped out and came back with a bottle of Coke for some participants and nothing for others. When the session ended, Joe said he was selling raffle tickets and asked if they would buy some. Those who had received a Coke bought twice as many tickets as those who had not. The bigger surprise was this: among those who got no Coke, the more they liked Joe, the more tickets they bought, but those who got a Coke bought just as many whether they liked him or not.[1] One free gift jumped right past liking.
In this story
Musk’s Coke
In December 2024, Musk’s xAI opened Grok, until then reserved for paying subscribers, to every user on X for free. Ten questions every two hours, a few images. A free AI assistant moved into an app used by hundreds of millions of people.[2] OpenAI and Google have given away parts of their best models as well. Every AI company has started handing out Cokes.
Musk hands out Cokes in disasters, too. He has given away Starlink in regions hit by hurricanes, and in the next great blackout of the AI age, it will be Musk, not the government, who turns the lights back on. The people connected that day do not forget who did it.
Also read: The Mars Settlers Musk's AI Picks Will All Carry the Gene That Can't Stop: The Explorer Gene
The animal that repays
Gifts come with a duty to repay. In The Gift, published in 1925, the French anthropologist Marcel Mauss compared the gift customs of Pacific Islanders and Indigenous peoples of North America and found the same three duties everywhere: to give, to receive and to repay. Those who could not repay ended up beneath the giver.[3]
Evolution built this instinct. In 1971 the American evolutionary biologist Robert Trivers explained how helping between unrelated individuals could survive. If I help you today and you repay me tomorrow, we both outlast anyone on their own. So humans evolved to remember what they received, to get angry at those who do not repay and to feel uneasy when they cannot repay.[4] That unease was born in bands of a few dozen people sharing the meat of a hunt. It works just the same when the giver is a company handing a Coke to hundreds of millions of people at once.

The debt is not paid in money
People who use free AI repay in other currencies. The first is data: every question trains the next model. The second is time: the longer the daily conversation with AI, the more room for ads and subscriptions. The third is the biggest, and it is voice. When the company is attacked, users push back on its behalf. When regulation looms, users sign. In Regan’s experiment, students who got a Coke bought raffle tickets even if they did not like Joe. Users of free AI defend that AI even if they do not like Musk.
In Influence, the American psychologist Robert Cialdini held up the Hare Krishna devotees in 1970s American airports as a textbook case of this instinct. They pressed a flower into a passing traveler’s hand first, then asked for a donation. The travelers did not want the flowers and sometimes dropped them in a trash can a few steps later, but before that, they opened their wallets.[5]

September 2037: a soup shop owner signs
September 2037, a pork-and-rice soup restaurant in Seomyeon, Busan. Mi-kyung, 58, has used a free AI assistant for eight years. Every morning it handles her ingredient orders and reservations, it translates her menu into Japanese and English, and every year it files her income tax. She has never paid a cent for it.
That evening the news reports that the National Assembly is debating a bill to stop that AI from collecting personal data. At the bottom of the screen, the AI company posts a “Save Free AI” petition. Mi-kyung puts down her dish towel and signs. She has been given so much, after all. Her daughter, a high school student doing homework at the next table, looks up. “Mom, it’s free because you’re the product.” Mi-kyung does not answer and goes back to wiping the soup bowls. That week, 12 million South Koreans signed.

3 billion users by 2027, a warning label by 2045
This is the order in which free AI turns into loyalty.
- 2027: More than 3 billion people worldwide use free AI every week. Most have never paid.
- 2030: An AI company gathers 10 million user signatures against a regulatory bill, the first large case of a company mobilizing its users as a political force.
- 2034: A large study finds that the longer people have used a free AI, the more they oppose regulating the company behind it, whether or not they like that company.
- 2040: In U.S. elections, AI companies’ user groups move more votes than labor unions do.
- 2045: The European Union requires free AI services to explain “why this service is free” on the first screen, like the warning on a pack of cigarettes.
Regan’s students got one bottle of Coke and bought twice as many raffle tickets. What Musk has handed to hundreds of millions of people is ten questions every two hours. That debt gets repaid slowly, over decades, in signatures, votes and voices.
Next in the series · Even as Population Collapses, Musk Will Multiply the “Number of Consciousnesses” With AI: Population Collapse
The Lancet projects that by 2100 only 6 of 204 countries will have fertility above replacement level. Human bodies grow fewer, but the number of thinking beings grows through AI.
Homo Conspirans: The Humans Who Come After Us · Part 20 of 27
Part 21 arrives Nov. 21.
← Part 19: After Albania's AI Minister, Musk's Dream of AI Government Comes Next: Diella
Read next
Trending on Seol Notes
- There Are No Seats Left at the Online Temple Where You Can't Talk to Anyone
- A Cat With a Gun Made $260,000 in a Day
- Two Years Away, Kim Seol-hyun Returns to Face Song Hye-kyo in Netflix's Tantara
- A Copycat Sold His Solo-Made Game Before He Could
- It Took RESCENE Two Years to Hit No. 1. This Time It Took Two Hours.
Sources
- Dennis T. Regan, “Effects of a favor and liking on compliance,” Journal of Experimental Social Psychology 7(6), 627–639, 1971. https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-1031(71)90025-4
- TechCrunch, report on Grok opening to all free X users (10 prompts every 2 hours), December 6, 2024. https://techcrunch.com/2024/12/06/2927301
- Marcel Mauss, Essai sur le don (The Gift), L’Année sociologique, 1925.
- Robert L. Trivers, “The Evolution of Reciprocal Altruism,” The Quarterly Review of Biology 46(1), 35–57, 1971. https://doi.org/10.1086/406755
- Robert B. Cialdini, Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion, William Morrow, 1984, Chapter 2, “Reciprocation.”
Discover more from Seol Notes
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.